Shape Up America! Newsletter
Treating Obesity in 12 to 18 Year Olds
by Barbara J. Moore, PhD
The medical journal, Pediatrics,
published a
series of articles1-4 on the
assessment,1
treatment2 and
prevention3 of childhood
obesity. Treatment of younger children, was
covered in the October
and November
2008
issues of this
newsletter and in detail in the treatment
report published in
Pediatrics.2
This article
is the last in our series on pediatric
obesity treatment and briefly summarizes the
recommended treatment of 12 to 18 year olds
—
a broad age range that covers a period of
rapid social and emotional development and
increasing autonomy.
The treatment approach for 12-year-olds, who
eat most meals at home and are more strongly
influenced by parents and family, will be
very different than for older teens, who eat
many meals outside the home and make
fundamental lifestyle decisions for
themselves. For example, in older teens,
assessing readiness to change is important.
Overweight teens who are ready for weight
loss may choose ineffective over-the-counter
drugs, purging or other dangerous self-help
strategies to address a weight problem. To
keep teens safe, parents and health care
providers should be aware of the various
steps in the treatment process recommended
for this age group.
Step 1: The first step in the treatment
process for 12 to 18 year olds is assessment
based on precisely measured height and weight and
calculation of body mass index (BMI). Some
teens who have a normal BMI or who are
underweight have a distorted self-image and
perceive themselves as overweight. Using
objective criteria to discuss what
constitutes a healthy weight may be a
valuable tool in reshaping a teen's impaired
self-image.
Step 2: Determine the gender- and
age-specific BMI
percentile and mark it
on the teen's personal BMI growth chart.
Compare the current BMI percentile to that
from previous years to see if a trend is
emerging. Although you can expect some
variation from year to year, growth should
track, or follow a certain percentile,
reasonably well over time.
Step 3: Use the BMI percentile to
determine
the teen's current weight category and to
choose the appropriate treatment path for
that category as shown in the table below. An
explanation of the treatment strategies for
the different weight categories follows this
table.
|
BMI Percentile
|
Category
|
Treatment Strategy
|
|
< 5th Percentile
|
Underweight
|
Professional monitoring (especially important
if there is a downward trend, which may
signal an eating disorder or other medical
problem)
|
|
5th to 84th Percentile
|
Normal weight
|
Prevention and at least yearly assessment of
BMI percentile, noting trends either upward
or downward
|
|
85th to 94th Percentile
|
Overweight
|
Prevention Plus; advance to Structured Weight
Management after 3-6 months if BMI percentile
increasing, medically warranted and/or if
parental obesity present. Goal is to maintain
weight with growth of teen until BMI is
< 85th
percentile, or slow weight gain to achieve a
downward trend in BMI percentile
|
|
95th to 99th Percentile
|
Obese
|
Prevention Plus; advance to Structured Weight
Management after 3-6 months if BMI percentile
increasing, medically warranted and/or if
parental obesity present. Goal is to lose
weight until BMI is < 85th percentile (See
note)
|
|
> 99th Percentile
|
Obese
|
Prevention Plus; advance to Structured Weight
Management after 3-6 months if no
improvement, then advance to Comprehensive
Multidisciplinary Intervention after 3-6
months if medically warranted and/or if
parental obesity present. Goal is to lose
weight (See note). Advancement to Tertiary
Care Interventions may be warranted if
comorbidity is present
|
Note: The expert committee treatment
report2
states that for obese teens, the rate of
weight loss should not exceed 2 pounds per
week. If weight loss exceeds this rate, the
health care provider should evaluate further
for causes of excessive weight loss.
Underweight: Teens who are underweight
should
be evaluated by a qualified health care
professional. Although it can be expected
that some very thin teens are perfectly
normal, to be on the safe side, professional
evaluation of teens at the 5th percentile or
below is needed to rule out the possibility
of eating disorders, distorted self image or
some other medical or developmental problems
that should be addressed.
Normal weight: As for all children, the
growth pattern of normal weight teens should
be monitored by assessing them yearly and
plotting BMI percentile on the teen's BMI
growth chart. Although you can expect BMI
percentile to vary from year to year, annual
updating of the teen's growth charts permits
detection of an unusually large change that
may signal unhealthy weight gain (or loss).
Prevention: Strategies to prevent
unhealthy/excessive weight gain in normal
weight teens are discussed in detail in the
prevention report.3 They include
playing and
being physically active for 60 minutes or
more per day; limiting TV and other sedentary
recreation to no more than 2 hours per day;
removing TV from the bedroom; eating 5 or
more servings of fruits and vegetables per
day plus other healthful foods (whole grains,
lean meats, eggs, fish, poultry and low fat
or fat free dairy) needed for growth;
limiting or eliminating soda, pop or other
sugar-sweetened beverages and fruit drinks;
limiting eating out; starting each day with a
healthy breakfast; enjoying regular family
meals and activities that involve the whole
family.
Overweight (85th-94th percentile): More
frequent professional monitoring of weight
status and lifestyle (every 3-6 months) of
overweight teens is needed, particularly if
medical issues or parental obesity are
present; this is referred to as Prevention
Plus. To the basic Prevention
strategies
described above, Structured Weight Management
(SWM) may be added that targets the entire
family rather than the teen. Thus, family
readiness to change must be assessed, and for
older teens who are more autonomous,
individual readiness must be determined. If
ready, SWM involves structured daily meals
and snacks that emphasize healthful foods
that are low in calories yet high in
nutritional quality; limiting meals taken
outside the home, including fast food.
Further reductions in daily TV and other
sedentary recreation to no more than 1 hour
per day may be needed. It is helpful to keep
a diary
of daily physical activity and all
foods and beverages with amounts consumed at
home and when eating out. Food diaries should
be monitored by a qualified health care
professional, usually a registered dietitian
(RD), but sometimes a physician or nurse
practitioner with appropriate training. The
emphasis is on healthy lifestyle change for
the entire family. (Note: A teen who
steadily
tracks in the overweight range, i.e., no
upward trend in BMI percentile, and has no
medical or family risks is likely to be at
low risk for excess fat. This teen can remain
on the regular prevention strategy that
applies to normal weight teens)
Obese (95th - 99th percentile): The
treatment progression for obese teens is
similar to that for overweight teens
described above, but monthly follow up with
assessments is recommended. If progress is
not made after 3-6 months, conduct family
(and teen) assessment of readiness to change
(see details in prevention
report3) and move
to SWM if family is ready. Greater
support,
increased structure of daily routine for both
healthy eating and exercise, and greater
oversight of eating and activity to insure
compliance is recommended. Reinforcement for
the achievement of behavioral goals is
suggested. Lack of improvement may warrant
advancement to Comprehensive
Multidisciplinary Intervention, which is
briefly explained below.
Obese > 99th percentile: For these
teens, in
addition to the above treatment strategies, a
Comprehensive Multidisciplinary Intervention
(CMI) strategy may be warranted. The CMI team
might include a specially trained
psychologist, exercise specialist, nurse
practitioner and/or dietitian in addition to
a physician. CMI is marked by increased
intensity of behavioral change strategies,
frequency of visits (initially weekly for a
minimum of 8-12 weeks, and then tapering off
to at least monthly) for professional
monitoring that includes assessment,
counseling and guidance, and service delivery
by appropriately trained specialists. The
five components of CMI are: 1) parental
involvement; 2) assessment of family and teen
lifestyle and BMI (or body fat) status; 3)
behavioral change plan that includes goal
setting and training in anticipating
challenges and problem solving; 4)
parent/caregiver training; 5) specific diet
and activity interventions that result in
negative energy balance (i.e., calories
expended exceed calories consumed) while
safeguarding nutritional quality and avoiding
a rate of weight loss that exceeds 2
pounds
per week.
High risk Tertiary Care Intervention (TCI)
may be warranted for an obese teen who is
afflicted with obesity comorbidities (e.g.,
type 2 diabetes) provided the teen fully
understands the possible risks of treatment
and possesses the maturity to responsibly
engage in both the treatment process and
necessary follow-up. TCI may involve meal
replacements, very-low-energy diets,
medications or even bariatric surgery, which
carries significant risk even under an
experienced doctor's supervision. The
treatment report2 provides more
details.
The scientific evidence on the recommended
components of treatment of teens is of
variable quality. The staged approach to
treatment is a responsible one that is based
on the best evidence currently available. As
the evidence strengthens with more research,
refining these guidelines by subdividing
teens into at least two groups, based on age
or level of maturity, may eventually become
possible.
In conclusion, health care professionals who
treat overweight and obese children of any
age are reminded to:2
-
Encourage healthy behaviors in their
patients and their families
-
Employ motivational techniques for
patients and their families ready for
lifestyle change
-
Establish office systems that support
monitoring and ongoing care
-
Implement a staged approach to
interventions as described above
-
Tailor the intervention to the
individual child and family
Barbara J. Moore, PhD, is President and
CEO of Shape Up America!
Motivating Teens to Get Moving
by Josh Trout, PhD
Being physically active for at least 60
minutes every day is especially crucial for
children struggling with weight issues. One
of the goals of physical education teachers
is to introduce children to a wide range of
activities and skills so that each can find
something physically active that they enjoy
doing every day for the rest of their lives.
Physical education teachers want youth to
love and embrace physical activity.
Many overweight children report having bad
experiences in physical education, not
because of the curriculum, but because they
are often concerned about how their peers
perceive them in physical education. This can
be a barrier to enjoying activity and can
discourage participation. Overweight and
obese youth carry social, psychological and
emotional burdens that often lead to anger,
despair, and ultimately, a sedentary
lifestyle. One example is picking teams.
Overweight youth dread being picked last, so
a more sensitive approach is for an adult to
set up the teams in advance to avoid a
potentially humiliating experience.
Teens should be encouraged to take
responsibility for their own health by making
wise nutritional choices and engaging in the
recommended 60 minutes of physical activity
per day. This does not necessarily mean
joining a gym to attend high-intensity
cardio-sculpting classes. Some research
indicates that many overweight teens prefer
to exercise in private so their peers do not
see them.1 There are many
activities that an
emerging exerciser can participate in at home
so that adopting healthier habits does not
come with a social or financial price tag. It
does, however, require active decision-making
and personal goal setting.
Some possibilities are exergaming (e.g.,
Nintendo® Wii™, Dance Dance
Revolution) at
home, renting a yoga DVD to follow in
private, or even taking a peaceful nature
hike. If exercising with others is more
motivating or just more fun, options include
walking, jogging or bicycling with friends,
taking classes such as martial arts or
Yogalates (Yoga + Pilates), or even
volunteering as a dog walker at the Humane
Society.
Teens should avoid anything that advertises a
quick solution such as an exercise machine
promising the body of your dreams in just
a few weeks, a new diet that can shed 30
pounds in 30 days, or a pill that boosts your
metabolism and claims to allow you to lose
weight while you sleep or eat whatever you
want. The vast majority of over-the-counter
pills and supplements for weight loss are
untested and ineffective; some are dangerous.
Some exercise machines are expensive yet
poorly designed, and consequently, are hard
on your back. If you are determined to invest
in a piece of exercise equipment, studies
show that a treadmill is most likely to be of
value in a home-based setting, but these
studies have been conducted in adults and may
not apply to teens.
Proper nutrition combined with daily physical
activity is the safest, most effective
long-term weight loss/maintenance plan.
Weight loss goals vary slightly depending on
a teen's current weight category (see
Treating Obesity in 12 to 18 Year Olds,
above), but for those who need to lose
weight, a reasonable goal is a gradual weight
loss of about 1 pound per week. This may
sound too slow for some, but consider this:
With 52 weeks in a year, it is possible to
lose 52 pounds by this time next year. If a
person takes it slow and adopts healthier
habits along the way, the weight loss
achieved is more likely to be permanent.
The greatest weapon in battling the obesity
epidemic is education. Overweight youth must
learn what foods to choose, as well as the
principles of portion control. Daily physical
activity is simply a health requirement.
Teens learn healthful practices from parents
and teachers who value and role-model
these
behaviors. It is not unlike teaching children
to buckle their seat belts, brush their
teeth, or avoid tobacco; it is a lifestyle
choice that must be taught by people who
practice these behaviors.
The human body is like a high-performance
race car: If you fill it with low-quality
fuel and park it, it will deteriorate. If it
receives racing fuel and driving time on the
track, it thrives. The human body also needs
good fuel (proper nutrition) and movement
(daily physical activity) to achieve and
maintain optimal health and wellness
throughout the lifespan. By learning these
lessons, teens will be more likely to achieve
and maintain optimal health and wellness
throughout their lifespan.
Josh Trout, PhD, is assistant
professor in the Department of Kinesiology at
California State University, Chico, and is
the author of the recently released book,
Supersized
PE: A Comprehensive Guidebook for Teaching
Overweight Students by the National
Association for Sport and Physical Education
(NASPE).
Green and Lean
by Barbara J. Moore, PhD
This is the first article in a series on how
you can shrink your carbon footprint, as well
as your waistline
without vaporizing your money — and in
today's economy, that's a smart move.
To accomplish this, a good place to start is
your food budget. Food is one place where we
can really trim the fat — by preparing
meals
at home and eating greener and smarter. Here
are some things you can do to go green and lean:
-
Side step the nonessentials, like
soda/pop, beer, candy, cookies, cakes and
chips. Sit down and figure out how much
money you are spending on such products each
year, and calculate the savings in dollars,
not to mention the savings in calories, if
you cut way back. You'll likely be in for a
big surprise. The savings in product
packaging that does not wind up in a landfill
is an added bonus.
-
Eat in instead of out. Even fast food is a
budget buster and often involves plastics and
other packaging that is used once and then
discarded. The fast food value meals may be
cheap today, but expensive tomorrow when you
are faced with the costs of treating obesity
and diabetes that are linked to a poor diet.
Because they depend on a constant flow of
massive quantities of uniform types of food
(corn-based sweetener for soda, a single type
of potato for French Fries, or mountains of
beef for burgers), fast food chains are
necessarily linked to industrial or factory
farming techniques and the loss of many
varieties of vegetables and fruit.
To meet the enormous demand for fast food,
agricultural production is focused on single
crop farming and large animal feedlots or
caged poultry that produce massive amounts of
animal and other chemical and biological
wastes that are polluting our air, rivers and
streams. Studies show a lower-calorie intake
and improved nutritional profile for meals
prepared at home, so if you can cut back on
eating out and learn to shop only once a week
for your groceries, you will gain several
benefits. In addition to consuming fewer
calories, you will begin to influence
agricultural production, reduce materials
required for packaging fast foods, and save
on gasoline, thereby reducing carbon
emissions and saving dollars.
-
Cut down on convenience foods. Although
roasted chickens, deli salads and pre-washed
salad greens are time-savers, they cost a
bundle and almost always involve packaging
that winds up in a landfill. Instead, you can
develop your own homemade convenience foods
and store them in green reusable containers
that don't wind up in the garbage. Purchase a
fresh head of lettuce and wash the leaves in
cold water, yourself. Thoroughly dry them and
store them wrapped loosely in a paper towel,
inside a plastic bag. Place in the
refrigerator vegetable bin, so they will stay
crisp and ready for your use throughout the
week. Prepare soups and stews on weekends and
enjoy them throughout the week to save both
time and money. Home-prepared foods are
likely to be lower in calories than their
store-bought counterparts.
-
Eat more plants and fewer animals. Animal
protein is high in quality and nutritious,
but there is no doubt that a plant-based diet
is literally greener and requires less energy
(fossil fuels) to produce. Reductions in
massive agricultural animal production will
reduce the required antibiotic usage in
factory farms and cut down on animal waste
and other contaminants that run off into our
ground water. So start collecting new recipes
for low-cost beans and legumes and other
vegetarian fare, and use meat sparingly.
These are strategies that are consistent with
effective weight management since the vast
majority of plant foods are naturally low in
fat and, thus, less energy (or calorie) dense
than animal foods, especially when plant
foods are prepared at home with minimal fats
or oils.
-
Start now to plan a garden so you will be
ready when spring comes. What could be
greener? You can grow your own fresh produce
or at least some fresh herbs in a window box.
A diet composed of more veggies is less
energy dense and helpful for weight
management. An additional lean benefit is
that gardening is a great way to exercise and
burn calories.
-
Replace calorie-rich soda with water,
preferably from the tap. If you really want
the convenience of portable bottled water,
buy a reusable (greener) bottle from a
sporting goods store. If you object to the
taste of your local tap water, invest in a
water filter, such as Brita®, that
will improve the taste and still save you
money compared to buying
bottled water.
-
Contact Shape Up
America! with more green and lean ideas
that we can share with our readers.
Menus for Weight Loss and Healthy Eating
Shape Up America! offers these simple,
convenient 1500
calorie and 2000
calorie menus to help
you eat healthfully while controlling your
calories.
Recipe of the Month
This unique recipe combines vegetables with fruit, along with a curry-yogurt dressing for a tasty and different type of chicken salad.
Curried Chicken Salad
Makes 4 servings
INGREDIENTS:
-
1 1/2 cups cooked chicken, skin
removed, cubed
-
1/4 cup carrots, peeled and grated
-
1/4 cup celery, peeled and chopped
-
1 cup red cabbage, shredded
-
1/4 cup granny smith green apple, chopped
-
1/4 cup scallions, trimmed and chopped
-
1/4 cup raisins
-
1/8 teaspoon celery seed
For dressing:
-
1 cup plain, non-fat yogurt
-
1 Tbsp. non-fat mayonnaise
-
3 tsp. curry powder
-
3 Tbsp. fresh lemon juice
-
Salt and freshly ground pepper to taste
-
1 Tbsp. Dijon-style-style mustard
-
2 Tbsp. shallots, finely chopped
DIRECTIONS:
-
Combine chicken, carrot, celery,
raisins, shredded cabbage, apple, scallions
and celery seed in a bowl.
-
Combine all dressing ingredients with
whisk in bowl. Pour over salad, mix well.
Cover and refrigerate one hour.
-
To serve, place on a bed of greens such
as lettuce combined with shredded red and
green cabbage.
Nutritional analysis per serving: 185
calories, 2.5 grams total fat, 0.5 gram
saturated fat, 20 grams carbohydrate, 21
grams protein, 2 grams dietary fiber, 300
milligrams sodium, 150 milligrams calcium.
Source: Shape Up
America!
|
|
phone:
406-686-4844
|
 |
Feel free to forward this newsletter to friends or
colleagues (click on Forward e-mail below). If you
have not yet signed up for your own FREE monthly
online subscription, or would like more information
on Shape Up America!, go to http://www.shapeup.org.
Email
addresses are maintained solely for newsletter use.
Shape Up America! will not sell, rent, or share your
address with a third party for non-newsletter
purposes. Past issues are available at our
newsletter
archive.
Editor: Adrienne Forman, MS, RD
|
|
|