|
Shape Up America! Newsletter
Greetings!
Artificial Sweeteners for Weight Management: Do They Work?
by Barbara J. Moore, PhD
The warnings about the dangers of sugary soft drinks
are everywhere, but there are also media reports
about the dangers of artificially sweetened
alternatives. To dispel some of the confusion and
put it all into perspective, it is important to take
a critical look at the science, especially the
relevant studies in humans.
A 2005 study of overweight Latino children linked
higher consumption of sugar and sugar-sweetened
beverages with reduced beta-cell function. (Beta
cells are pancreatic cells that make and secrete
insulin.)1 In other words, these
overweight children were beginning to show signs of
impaired pancreatic function, which means they are
on their way to developing type 2 diabetes. The
authors emphasized the need to reduce daily sugar
intake, including drinking less sugar-sweetened
beverages, to avert disease.
In adults, a 2006 study2 linked higher
consumption of sugar-sweetened soft drinks with a
greater risk of weight gain, especially in people who
are overweight. These two studies add to existing
evidence3,4,5 that sweetened drinks
need to be curtailed, or even eliminated, to avert
Diabesity® -- that is, obesity and
type 2
diabetes.
According to Popkin and colleagues,6
Americans are consuming an average of 150 to 300
extra (i.e., unnecessary) calories each day. This is
equivalent to drinking one to two 12-ounce cans of
cola daily. Every day, many young people often drink
more sugary beverages7 than two cans
of soda or other sweetened juice drinks. Many
authorities believe that soda is contributing to the
Diabesity® epidemic in America.
Americans who lead a sedentary lifestyle are
particularly at risk. Jacobs8 has
advanced the Taylor Hypothesis that argues
that (1)
energy balance—in which the calories you burn
equals the calories you eat—is promoted by high
energy expenditure through physical activity and (2)
energy imbalance that promotes obesity is due to a
sedentary lifestyle marked by low energy expenditure
(i.e., low levels of physical activity). In other
words,
your physiology and metabolism that ordinarily
assures energy balance works less efficiently when
your energy expenditure is low, so obesity develops
more readily in people who are physically inactive.
Conversely, energy balance is easier to maintain
when you are highly active.
Alarmed by the growing epidemic of obesity and the
high intake of sweetened beverages,
Popkin6 urges that drinking water be
used as the "preferred beverage" to fulfill daily water
needs. Although we support Popkin’s position on
water, we believe that many people will resist
replacing all calorie-laden sweetened beverages with
water, and many will turn to zero-calorie "diet" drinks
instead.
Diet drinks are formulated to taste sweet but
deliver zero calories. Paradoxically, several
short-term studies, summarized by Tordoff and
Alleva,9 suggest that sweet taste
triggers a "metabolic reflex" that increases appetite.
This might lead to an increase in body weight over
the long run, but fortunately, long-term studies show
that diet drinks do not cause weight gain. Rather,
they appear to be useful in weight management.
Three key long-term studies are summarized below:
Tordoff and Alleva9 gave one group of
normal weight men and women conventional soda
(530 calories per day) and a second group the same
volume of diet soda (sweetened with aspartame).
The researchers found that in the group drinking
sugar-sweetened soda, total daily calories consumed
and body weight increased, but in the group drinking
aspartame-sweetened soda, calories consumed and
body weight decreased. No safety problems were
reported.
Raben and coworkers10 studied two
groups of people for 10 weeks, to see how
consuming two types of supplements would affect
their daily calorie intake and body weight. The
control group ate a diet that included supplemental
drinks and foods containing sucrose (i.e., regular
table sugar). The other group had similar drinks and
foods that contained artificial sweeteners in place of
sugar. Both groups were required to eat a minimum
amount of the supplements each day, but the rest of
their diet was not restricted. During the study, the
sucrose group steadily gained weight while the
artificial sweetener group steadily lost weight. The
majority of the weight gain (1.6 kg or 3.5 pounds) in
the sucrose group was primarily due to increased fat.
Blackburn and coworkers11 carried out
a very long-term study of obese female dieters. One
group of women was instructed how to lose weight in
a comprehensive program that included
aspartame-containing beverages and foods. The
control group of
dieters received the same weight-loss instruction but
was discouraged from using these products. The
weight loss in the two groups was virtually identical
for the first 19 weeks of the study. But three years
later, the aspartame group regained significantly less
weight and the conventionally-treated group
regained all of their lost weight. The authors noted
that despite other studies claiming to the contrary,
the aspartame group did not report an increase in
hunger at any time during the study. The 5% weight
loss achieved in the aspartame group was considered
to be clinically significant, and no significant health
problems were reported.
Taken together, these studies agree with earlier
careful work by Porikos and
colleagues12,13 who showed that both
lean and obese subjects living in a metabolic ward
consumed fewer calories when the researchers
covertly substituted aspartame for all the sucrose in
their diets. It is clear that the long-term use of
artificial sweeteners does NOT stimulate hunger, was
not associated with safety problems, and can be
useful for achieving weight loss in a dieting
population. Zero-calorie sugar substitutes are an
easy way to reduce or eliminate sugar-sweetened
beverages that are increasingly being linked to
Diabesity®. They may be useful not
just for
dieting,
but also for preventing weight gain in a normal
weight population.
Bottom Line: Although the data are not
ironclad, studies in humans increasingly point to the
dangers of consuming sugary soft drinks and the
need to moderate sugar intake to avert obesity and
disease. Long-term studies in humans support the
use of artificially-sweetened beverages in managing
weight. Although water is our preferred beverage
choice, artificially-sweetened drinks are a better
choice than sugar-sweetened beverages. We
support the call to reduce sugar intake, especially
sugar-sweetened beverages.
Triceps Training
by Michael Roussell
This month our featured muscle group is the triceps,
the lesser known of the two upper arm muscles—the
other being the biceps. When people talk about
upper arm muscles, they often mean the biceps. Yet,
the triceps muscle makes up almost 2/3 of your upper
arm, making them a very important, though often
neglected, muscle group.
The triceps muscles are used in a pushing movement,
usually along with the chest and shoulder muscles.
The triceps were briefly mentioned in the September
2005 Shape Up America! newsletter article on push
ups. (You can find that article in the
newsletter archives at shapeup.org.)
This month we are going to look at several variations
of a movement that specifically works the triceps
muscles – bench dips.
To perform bench dips, all you will need is a bench
that is placed directly against a wall so that it
won’t slip while you perform the exercise. I have
also used a chair for this exercise, but since my
chair is too narrow to allow me to sit on the edge
and at the same time grip the front edge of the
chair, I put two chairs together as shown in the
illustration below. So don’t hesitate to grab a
second chair if a bench is not available.
|
For safety’s sake, position the bench or chairs
right next to each other, and back them up against a
wall to ensure they will not slip or move as you
perform this exercise.
|
There are two variations of this exercise, one with
your legs bent (which is the beginner position) and
another with your legs straight (which is more
difficult). To start this movement, you will need
to sit (or more accurately, "perch") on the very
edge of the bench, or chairs, and place both hands
on the front edge on either side of your body.
Place your hands so your entire palms are on the
bench and your fingers are gripping it firmly.
Next, place your feet together in front of you so
that your knees are bent and your feet are flat on
the ground. Now you are ready to start the
movement.
Slide your rear end off the bench so now only your
arms are holding you up. With your elbows pointing
backwards, slowly bend your arms and lower your
bottom towards the ground – just far enough so that
a right angle forms at your elbow joint. Stop at
that point and reverse the movement, pushing your
hands into the bench and straightening out your
arms. When you reach the top of the movement, stop
just before you lock your elbows; this will keep
your triceps working for the entire movement.
Now take a breath and repeat until you reach your
rep goal. This goal will vary depending on your
fitness level. (See table below). You only need to
do it once a week.
| Goal Level |
Sets/Reps |
Comments |
| Beginner |
1 set, 10-12 reps |
When you move from one
skill level to the next, you may have difficulty
reaching your rep goal. That’s OK. Go as far as you
can and try to add one or two more reps each
workout.
|
| Intermediate |
2 sets, 10-12 reps |
| Advanced |
3 sets, 10-12 reps |
This movement is simple, but very effective. To make
it more difficult, straighten your legs and stretch
them out before you, so that only your heels are
touching the ground.
Next month we will complete upper arm training with
a movement that strengthens the biceps.
Resting Metabolic Rate Calculator Available on SUA Website
Your Resting Metabolic Rate, or RMR, is the rate at
which your body burns calories when at rest. Even
when you’re sitting, you need calories to sustain
vital body functions. It’s important to know your
RMR, especially if you’re trying to lose weight,
because if you restrict calories below your RMR,
your rate of weight loss will slow and your health
may suffer.
Shape Up America! has a
RMR calculator that you can use to estimate
your resting calorie needs for the day. For more
information on metabolism, see
Step 7 of the Shape Up & Drop 10
program)
Recipe of the Month
This fat-free guacamole is made with asparagus. Use it as a dip or try it on chicken, an omelet or lean burger.
NO GUILT ASPARAGUS GUACAMOLE
Serves 2
INGREDIENTS:
- 10 1/2 oz. fresh, trimmed or frozen, cut
asparagus
- 1/4 tsp. garlic powder
- 2 tsp. lime juice (lemon juice may be
substituted)
- 2 Tbsp. canned green chili peppers, drained,
chopped
- 1 Tbsp. onion, chopped
- 2 tsp. tomato paste
- 1/8 tsp. salt
- 1/4 tsp. ground cumin
- 1/8 tsp. white pepper
DIRECTIONS:
-
Cook asparagus. Drain well, pat dry with paper
towels.
- Place asparagus in blender. Add remaining
ingredients. Blend until smooth. Dip will become less
thick upon standing and will need to be stirred.
Nutrition Information Per Serving:
25 calories, 0 grams fat, 0 milligrams cholesterol,
2 grams fiber, 142 milligrams sodium
Source: 5 A Day recipe,
http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dnpa/5aday/recipes
|
|
phone:
202-974-5051
|
 |
The Shape Up America! newsletter
Editor: Adrienne Forman, MS, RD
|
|
|